Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Alex Roddie's avatar

So much this. I think about these topics constantly – how Enlightenment thinking poisons the well of what we call the 'outdoors'. But equally I think a counterculture of Romanticism is brewing. Demons grow bold and hungry in the machine. Meaning can be found beyond it, and places are once more enchanted.

Matt Wells's avatar

You capture so well the strange mix of familiarity and awe we can feel for a mountain - you don’t need performative guilt as a framework to write about it.

A spiritual relationship with the natural world hasn’t been erased in the West, it has simply evolved (as it is evolving everywhere). Europe has its own traditions of sacred landscapes streching back over millenia, albeit expressed in folklore and art rather than mainstream religion. From Celtic hill shrines, Norse mountain myths and Christian pilgrimages to Romantic poetry and Re-wilding, that lineage hasn’t vanished; and your writing is part of it.

It’s also worth remembering that novelty and stereotype biases are universal, not unique to “white people” or Western culture. The rational-West vs. spiritual-non-West framing is a false dichotomy and isn't supported by history. Across time, utility and conquest have shaped our species' relationship with nature, just as much as awe and spirituality have. Colonialism, capitalism and science have blunted our emotional connection to the landscape around the globe but they haven’t erased it.

I think your gift as a writer is helping people remember that connection isn’t something we need to borrow from elsewhere - it’s here, waiting for us, if we pause long enough to recognise it. Reading your piece reminded me of the deeply spiritual times that I have spent in nature, some of those, on or around Helvellyn. Your voice is powerful when it leans into that wonder.

Rather than adopting a stance of moral outrage or cultural self-loathing, why not consider what traditions of reverence might we recover, or what modern rituals we could create?

Sometimes the best advice is simply to think less while you wonder more.

2 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?